I Thought Catholicism Was Heresy (w/Elias)
The Everyday Saint
I met Elias in high school. At the time, he was avidly anti-Catholic. Now, five years later, he's on fire for his CATHOLIC faith. What changed? In this episode, Elias shares his journey from Protestantism, to agnostic, to becoming Catholic. All things are on the table with this conversation: learning how to forgive yourself, navigating when you feel mad at God, and what it looks like to let God love you. Learn about Seton Teaching Fellows: https://fellows.setonpartners.org/saint Clean fiction books: https://jacqueline-brown.com/ Follow on Instagram: @theeverosemary Eve Rosemary is currently booking Catholic speaking engagements for the 2026–2027 school year. Learn more or inquire at: theeverydaysaint.com/speaking The Everyday Saint Catholic goods designed to support everyday holiness: theeverydaysaint.com/shop If this podcast has blessed you, please consider supporting the mission. Your generosity helps bring faithful, honest formation to teens and young adults across the country: theeverydaysaint.com/donate Subscribe, leave a review, and share this episode so we can pursue Something Greater together.
About Podcast
The Everyday Saint Podcast is a podcast delving into transparent, joyful, and honest truths about what it means to become a saint...not someday, but here and now. This isn’t about perfection or performance. It’s about learning to trust God in the ordinary, responding to His call with courage, and choosing faithfulness even when the path is unclear.
Hosted by Eve Rosemary (@theeverosemary), The Everyday Saint invites you to step into the lifelong pursuit of Something Greater—and reminds you that you are not walking that road alone.