VirTrue: Counsel (Consilium) a Part of Prudence
VirTrue - Helping Man Grow in Truth and Virtue
🎧 Intro Welcome to VirTrue where we work together to turn away from vice, and adopt the virtuous life we are all called to. I’m your host, Jethro Higgins. Today on VirTrue we’re going to talk about Counsel, or Consilium, which is a sub-virtue of Prudence according to the tradition inherited from Hugh of St. Victor and developed by St. Thomas Aquinas. This episode continues our journey through the integral parts of Prudence, following Memory, Intelligence, and Foresight. Quick reminder, the VirTrue app is currently in BETA testing. We need your feedback to help make it exactly what you need to grow in virtue. For a limited time, paid subscribers will receive early access to help shape the direction of the platform as we continue building tools to help people grow in virtue. Visit socialcatholic.substack.com to start a paid subscription both to support our work AND to get early access to the VirTrue app. 📖 Virtue Description Counsel is the habit of seeking right judgment before acting. It is the disciplined willingness to deliberate well. Prudence is often misunderstood as instinct, intuition, or quick decision-making. But St. Thomas Aquinas teaches that prudence is deeply connected to careful consideration. The prudent person does not rush headlong into action simply because they are confident. They pause. They examine. They deliberate. They seek counsel. St. Thomas Aquinas says: “To take good counsel and to judge well belong to prudence.” (Summa Theologiae, II-II, Q.51, A.3) Prudence is acting with Wisdom. It isn’t about knowing things; it’s about knowing how to deliberate well. The prudent man does not simply react. He slows down long enough to ask: * What is true here? * What is good here? * What leads toward God here? That process of honest deliberation is what Aquinas calls Counsel. And most people skip it entirely. Some rush ahead before the process of inquiry is complete. Others become trapped in endless analysis and never act at all. But prudence requires both: * good deliberation * and decisive action Counsel is a bridge between ignorance and wise action. A man with memory may remember the past. A man with intelligence may understand the present. A man with foresight may see the future trajectory. But without counsel, he may still act foolishly because he never slowed down long enough to deliberate well. Counsel requires humility because good deliberation often begins with admitting: “I may not see this clearly.” This is why counsel naturally involves other people. Scripture says: “Without counsel plans fail, but with many advisers they succeed.” (Proverbs 15:22) The prudent man does not assume every thought in his head is wisdom. He tests them. He questions himself. He seeks guidance from: * Scripture * Tradition * Wise mentors * Legitimate authority * The accumulated wisdom of the Church Counsel is not hesitation for its own sake. It is ordered deliberation directed toward action. The purpose of counsel is not endless discussion. The purpose of counsel is right action. This is also why counsel requires courage. Once deliberation is complete, action must follow. A person who seeks advice forever without acting has not perfected counsel. They have distorted it. ⚠️ Vice of Deficiency: Precipitation (Praecipitatio) Definition Precipitation is inordinate haste in decision-making that cuts short proper deliberation and inquiry. Why it fits St. Thomas Aquinas says: “Precipitation is a vice directly opposed to counsel.” (Summa Theologiae, II-II, Q.53, A.3) The precipitate person rushes to conclusions before judgment is fully formed. They: * Skip deliberation * Refuse inquiry * Ignore counsel * Act before understanding Precipitation is not merely speed. It is disordered speed. The problem is not acting quickly when circumstances require it. The problem is bypassing the process prudence demands. The precipitate person mistakes immediacy for wisdom. What it looks like * Making major decisions impulsively * Reacting emotionally before understanding * Correcting others publicly without context * Refusing guidance because “I already know” * Spiritual decisions made without discernment * Acting on outrage before investigating facts * Mistaking confidence for competence 🔥 Vice of Excess: Indecision (Indecisio) Definition Indecision is excessive deliberation that prevents timely action. Why it fits Counsel exists for the sake of action. The indecisive person becomes trapped in perpetual deliberation. Unlike the precipitate person who cuts inquiry short, the indecisive person never allows inquiry to end. He: * Needs one more opinion * One more article * One more conversation * One more reassurance He mistakes endless analysis for wisdom. This vice often disguises itself as carefulness. But underneath it is usually fear. Fear of: * Failure * Responsibility * Commitment * Consequences The indecisive person wants certainty before acting. But prudence rarely works with certainty. Prudence works with sufficient judgment. At some point, deliberation must end and action must begin. What it looks like * Paralysis over important decisions * Constant second-guessing * Endless research without commitment * Delaying repentance or vocation * Reopening settled questions repeatedly * Seeking advice mainly to avoid accountability The indecisive person lives permanently at the crossroads. 🧍 My Life At the risk of creating a pattern for this season, I struggle with both vices when it comes to counsel. Gathering the right amount of counsel is challenging for me. If I’m in a deliberating mindset, I can spin my wheels quite a bit waiting for the perfect answer to reveal itself, but I can also suddenly lurch out of that mindset into an action-oriented mindset. A classic example is during test-taking in school. When I got to the long-form questions, I would often deliberate for a long time on one question, then panic that I wasn’t managing my time well and quickly and decisively answer the remaining questions. This isn’t a case of time management, though. Another example is that I can move forward rather quickly with tasks where I feel like I have all the information I need, but when I don’t feel that confidence, I can switch into learning mode where I begin to seek counsel that extends far beyond the information needed to act decisively. This Podcast is actually a good example of this. I had this idea for both the podcast and the VirTrue app for 8 years before I took action. I wanted to be sure I had fully deliberated on the virtue model I was using, and I wanted to finish my Master’s degree in Theology, and and and... I found an endless number of needs that had to be fulfilled before I could take action. It was only when God allowed me to enter a period of great suffering that I surrendered to this idea he had been placing on my heart for almost a decade. He used my suffering to pull me out of endless deliberation and counsel seeking. An area of counsel seeking that I have excelled at in my career has been in user testing. I worked on a number of Catholic apps over the course of my career, and User testing really helped me to see the immediate value of getting feedback and adjusting your thinking accordingly. I’m in this phase with the VirTrue app right now. 🌍 The Secular Perspective Modern culture suffers from both extremes simultaneously. On one side, we glorify precipitation. “Trust yourself.” “Move fast.” “Disrupt everything.” The fastest reaction often wins. Social media rewards immediacy, not deliberation. Nobody gains influence online by saying: “I need time to think about this.” Modern media trains people to react before understanding. Outrage arrives faster than a well-measured response. At the same time, modern culture is drowning in indecision. We have endless information and almost no wisdom. People delay: * Marriage * Children * Career decisions * Conversion * Commitment Because modern life trains us to believe there is always a slightly better option waiting around the corner. We’ve become a culture defined by our failure to launch. Consumer culture has made commitment feel dangerous. Counsel as a virtue cuts through both errors. It teaches us to: * Deliberate honestly * Seek wisdom hum… Get full access to The Social Catholic at socialcatholic.substack.com/subscribe
About Podcast
socialcatholic.substack.com
